Hartside Cafe rebuild plans revised eight years after fire

The original Hartside Cafe before it was destroyed by fire <i>(Image: Johnny Becker)</i>
The original Hartside Cafe before it was destroyed by fire (Image: Johnny Becker)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.
Close Icon

Find, save and share Public Notices that affect you in the area.

Search the Public Notice Portal What is the Public Notice Portal?

What is the Public Notice Portal?

The Public Notice Portal carries statutory public notices published in local newspapers and is the fastest and most effective way of finding out what is happening in YOUR neighbourhood.

Search the Public Notice Portal

A landmark cafe destroyed by fire more than eight years ago could be rebuilt using seven shipping containers under newly submitted plans.

Hartside Cafe, on the A686 between Penrith and Alston, was once a hugely popular stopping point for motorcyclists, cyclists and motorists travelling across the North Pennines.

The building was destroyed by fire in March 2018 and has remained closed ever since, despite planning permission for a replacement being granted more than two years ago.

Now owner Sarah Dawn Dixon has submitted revised proposals to Westmorland and Furness Council, seeking to change the construction method of the long-awaited replacement.

Instead of the previously approved steel portal-frame structure, the cafe would be built using seven 40ft shipping containers, clad in Corten, a weathering steel which develops a distinctive rust-coloured appearance.

Explaining the proposed changes in her application, Mrs Dixon said:

"I wish to change the construction method from a steel portal frame to 7 x 40 ft shipping containers."

She confirmed that the development would remain within the same site boundary, with the previously proposed commercial waste treatment plant retained.

The application also proposes replacing the approved drawings with plans for "Modular Shipping containers clad in Corten".

Drawings submitted with the application show a single-storey building featuring large windows, a dining area, kitchen, servery, storage facilities and toilets, together with external decking.

At the time of the original approval in 2024, Mrs Dixon, who acquired the site in 2019, had expressed hopes that the cafe could reopen within nine months.

However, the rebuild has yet to get under way.

In June this year, the News & Star reported that a crowdfunding campaign had been launched to help finance the project.

Organisers estimated the overall cost of rebuilding the café at around £700,000, with an initial fundraising target of £24,000 and longer-term ambitions to raise £100,000 from supporters.

The appeal described the cafe as a much-needed community destination and expressed hopes of restoring its role as a gathering place for visitors to the summit.

A view of fields and a winding roadThe view west from Hartside summit in 2026 (Image: Darren Shield)

Standing approximately 1,904ft above sea level, the original Hartside Cafe was a well-known landmark, attracting visitors from across the county and beyond.

Its car park is still particularly popular with motorcyclists enjoying the winding A686 route, while its elevated position offered sweeping views across the Eden Valley and towards the Lake District.

The latest application, reference 2026/1589/FPA, was validated on October 28 and is now subject to public consultation.

Comments can be submitted to Westmorland and Furness Council until December 12, with a decision expected later that month.

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos