Best pizza in Carlisle according to TripAdvisor reviews

Pizzas come in all sizes, shapes and flavours and the argument over which toppings are acceptable and which aren’t will cause arguments for years to come.

But whether you like pineapple on your pizza or tuna, there are plenty of establishments in Carlisle that serve up great pizzas to suit all tastes.

To help you narrow down your options, we’ve trawled through TripAdvisor reviews to find where the best pizzas in Carlisle are.

Carlisle’s best pizza

Romano Pizzeria

TripAdvisor rating: 5/5
Where is it: Scotch Street 55 - 56 The Market Hall, Carlisle CA3 8QX

A full house rating sees Romano Pizzeria as one of the top places to get a pizza in Carlisle.

Romano Pizzeria (TripAdvisor)

Food, service and value are all given top marks by previous customers and reviewers have left rave reviews.

“Amazing”, “fantastic” and “delicious” are frequently used words to describe Romano Pizzeria.

Amato’s

TripAdvisor rating: 4.5/5
Where is it: 48 Abbey Street, Carlisle

Amato’s is described by reviewers as “a slice of Sicily” as customers praise the food quality and friendly staff.

Amato's (TripAdvisor)

One reviewer said they “couldn’t fault anything”.

Gianni’s Ristorante

TripAdvisor rating: 4.5/5
Where is it: 3 Cecil Street, Carlisle CA1 1NL

Gianni’s Ristorante (TripAdvisor)

Gianni’s is described by one reviewer as “the best little Italian ever”. Food and service both get rave reviews and have customers wanting to come back again and again.

Casa Romana Carlisle

TripAdvisor rating: 4.5/5
Where is it: 44 Warwick Road, Carlisle CA1 1DN

Casa Romana (TripAdvisor)

Casa Romana has mixed reviews but they are mainly positive, especially for vegan and gluten free visitors.

One review said it was a “traditional Italian that is very vegan friendly” and others praised their ability to cater to other dietary requirements.

Sannas

TripAdvisor rating: 4.5/5
Where is it: 30 Lowther Street, Carlisle CA3 8DH

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by SannaS (@sannas_restaurant)

Customers love the pizzas at Sannas, with several reviewers calling it the best Italian in Carlisle.

Specialising in Italian/Sardinian cuisine, customers seem to love returning to Sannas over and over again.

La Mezzaluna

TripAdvisor rating: 4.5/5
Where is it: 6 The Crescent, Carlisle CA1 1QW

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by La Mezzaluna (@mezzalunacarlisle)

An “old school” Italian, La Mezzaluna is a fan favourite in Carlisle. Both service and food are given high praise and reviewers can’t seem to get enough of the “top dollar Italian food”.