COUNCILLORS have refused the latest plans for a controversial development in the conservation area of a north Cumbrian village.

Proposals for two new flats in Skelton Court at Wetheral were unanimously rejected on the grounds they would have an impact on the conservation area and would infringe on a neighbouring listed building.

Carlisle City Council’s development control committee refused Citadel Estates’ request despite a recommendation to approve it.

The plan also asked for alterations to the building and layout of the site, including landscaping and parking along with the relocation of a bin store.

The existing 15-flat development has been contested by Wetheral residents for the past five years. Those present applauded the decision.


Barry Earp Councillor Barry Earp said he had counted up 10 applications on the development and had read over 700 pages of objections regarding the scheme. 

He said: “We’re really in a very awkward position. To my mind what has been built now doesn’t comply at all with what we had given permission for.”

Councillor Barrie Osgood said: “I’m concerned that the developer just seems to go on and on with whatever he seems to want to do.

“It’s time we took enforcement action when we can, if we can, to let people know that we are here to do what we’re supposed to do.”

Reacting to the news, Citadel’s owner Dean Montgomery said he was disappointed members chose to ignore the advice of professional officers. 

“We will address the reasons for refusal and submit a revised scheme imminently,” he added.

Almost 100 letters of objection were received.

Speaking at the meeting, one objector told members: “We believe your impending decision has wider-reaching implications. What is the value of the Carlisle District Plan if it is to be ignored by a developer, allowing him to build what he wants unhindered and without fear of enforcement.”