Carlisle judge queries man’s knife excuse
Last updated at 11:15, Monday, 26 November 2012
A man caught with a knife after trouble at a Cumbrian holiday village has claimed it was left over from his job at a food factory.
But a judge at Carlisle Crown Court was sceptical of the excuse after hearing that Lee Francis Burns had left that job three weeks before the incident.
Now Burns, 27, is going to have to give evidence to support his claim that he was carrying the Stanley knife for an innocent purpose.
His lawyers are also likely to ask his former employers in Manchester to confirm that he might have had good reason to still have the knife in his possession.
Burns, of Lees New Road, Oldham, was arrested after a disturbance at the Solway Holiday Village in Silloth on August 16.
The knife was found when police officers searched him after arresting him.
He pleaded guilty to charges of affray and having an article with a blade in a public place.
No details of the incident were given in court.
But his barrister Keith Thomas said there was no suggestion that Burns had waved the knife around or threatened anyone with it.
“This is at the very bottom end of an affray – there is no suggestion of actual violence and the like,” he said. “It is in fact words and behaviour more than anything else.”
Mr Thomas said Burns should be given credit for having kept out of trouble for so long after being released from a lengthy prison sentence in December 2010.
Judge Paul Batty QC said he was faced with “a stark choice” between sending Burns to prison or giving him a suspended jail sentence.
He said he could not decide until hearing evidence about why he had the knife.
Burns will be back in court on December 3.
He was remanded in custody.
First published at 11:11, Monday, 26 November 2012
Published by http://www.newsandstar.co.uk
Have your say
- Cumbria police pledge crackdown on illegal sale of weapons (1 comment)
- September decision on whether Americans will continue to run Sellafield (2 comments)
- 28 new housing sites in Carlisle unveiled (12 comments)
- National restaurant company eyeing Carlisle's Hoopers building (19 comments)
- Hope buyer can be found for Carlisle pub (7 comments)
- Families asked to scatter ashes on Lake District fells - not leave boxes (2 comments)
- Allerdale needs 200 affordable homes a year to help first time buyers (12 comments)
- Plans to cut speed limit on Carlisle road to 40mph (27 comments)
- Cumbria police used bus full of children as roadblock to stop car (57 comments)
- Anger as new homes approved despite 300 objections (42 comments)
Court & crime
Anne Pickles
- 28 new housing sites in Carlisle unveiled (12 comments)
- Allerdale needs 200 affordable homes a year to help first time buyers (12 comments)
- National restaurant company eyeing Carlisle's Hoopers building (19 comments)
- September decision on whether Americans will continue to run Sellafield (2 comments)
- Cumbria police pledge crackdown on illegal sale of weapons (1 comment)
- National restaurant company eyeing Carlisle's Hoopers building (19 comments)
- 28 new housing sites in Carlisle unveiled (12 comments)
- Allerdale needs 200 affordable homes a year to help first time buyers (12 comments)
- Gangs in Carlisle scouring rubbish bags for bank details - claim (11 comments)
- Cumbria police used bus full of children as roadblock to stop car (57 comments)
- Cumbria police used bus full of children as roadblock to stop car (57 comments)
- Anger as new homes approved despite 300 objections (42 comments)
- Trade chairman against Cumbria's summer road closures plan (39 comments)
- Carlisle city centre clothes shop closing down (33 comments)
- Hoopers store in Carlisle bought 'by mistake' at auction (32 comments)








