Carlisle flood prevention scheme deferred - after councillors could find no reason to refuse it

Some members of Carlisle's Development Control Committee were reluctant to approval an application for a sustainable urban drainage system, known as a SUDS pond, on Isobel's Green, Morton, because of safety concerns. The site is owned by Riverside.

The plans aimed to mitigate flood risk to properties in Westrigg Road, which is flooded by surface water during periods of heavy rain.

There were no objections from residents, but ward councillors John Bell and Colin Stothard objected to the open pond, stating that it created dangers and risks to residents of all ages, particularly children.

After a lengthy debate five councillors voted in favour of the officer's recommendations to approve the scheme, while seven voted against it.

Councillor Lucy Patrick said: "I feel reluctant to support this. I can't vote for this because it is introducing a risk at a place that doesn't have that at the moment."

Councillor Hugh McDevitt said: "I believe it is unsafe. There is no way I can vote for something that would put young people in danger."

But officers said it could not be refused on the grounds of safety and that instead planning policies reason were needed.

Councillor Nigel Christian proposed a deferral so officers and the developer could put a clearer proposal before the committee.

He didn't understand how the SUDS system worked and there were some aspects of the scheme he felt needed more detail.

Seven voted in favour of deferral while five opposed.

Councillor Heather Bradley was concerned that they were losing sight of the aim for a solution to flooding in the area.

Ray Bloxham, who supported the application, agreed with Mrs Bradley.

He said: "I accept all the things and I am concerned about safety but, if we don't have a policy reason for refusal the inspector will cast it out of hand. "The professionals are saying this is the scheme and they've got a report for the scheme that has been designed for the area. "