Thursday, 15 May 2008

Mercy dash carer in court for trying to help his epileptic wife

A FULL-TIME carer is facing a court appearance for speeding while his disabled wife was having an epileptic fit.

andy duffy
I’d do it again: Sydney Duffy and wife Rovina face a court appearance

Sydney Duffy, 63, was clocked doing 35mph in the 30mph zone on Beacon Edge, Penrith, on February 23 after his wife Rovina, who was sitting in the passenger seat, suffered her third fit of the day.

Sydney, who passed his driving test 43 years ago, has never received a speeding ticket before.

He says his foot must have hit the accelerator as he turned to see what was happening, but police have dismissed his appeal against the punishment – a £60 fine and three points – and ordered him to face magistrates.

He gave up his job as a supplier to the licensing trade to become Rovina’s full-time carer in 1986. She developed epilepsy after suffering from meningitis and brain surgery and now endures up to seven fits a day.

Sydney, who served in the Royal Artillery, told the News & Star: “I couldn’t believe it when I got the letter.

“I was stationed in Hong Kong and Germany and I’ve travelled all over the world, but I have never seen anything like this.

“Rovina is distraught. I tried to keep it from her at first but I had to tell her once the letters started coming through the door.

“Going to court is going to be quite traumatic for her.”

The couple, who have been married since 1963, will both have to attend the hearing because Rovina, also 63, is the registered owner of the Motability hired Vauxhall Zafira while Sydney is the registered driver.

Sydney, of Culgaith, said: “My priority was to get parked and get Rovina in a position where she couldn’t harm herself. I wouldn’t hesitate to do it again.

“I was frightened Rovina would swallow her tongue or bang her head on one of the doors or windows.”

Sydney, who is now considering paying the fine in the hope he will avoid court, says a picture taken by the mobile speed camera clearly shows Rovina holding her head in agony.

He added: “I know when it’s coming because she gets an excruciating pain in the back of her head and holds it.

“All of this has been explained to the police but they don’t seem to care.

“I’ve been a law-abiding person all of my life and would rather die than break the law. You would think they would consider cases like this in context rather than just dismissing them out of hand.”

Rovina, who uses a mobility scooter to get around, said: “He has always looked after me. It’s a 24-hour a day job with lots of stress. This is the last thing we need.”

A letter sent from the central ticket office at Cumbria Constabulary said arrangements are now being made for a court case.

It said: “Whilst I sympathise with the circumstances surrounding your wife’s health, and in particular on this journey, your speed was within the parameters where a fixed penalty will be processed and therefore the penalty will stand.

“Our file has already been submitted to the prosecutions department and you will be sent the relevant paperwork in due course.

“At the court hearing you will be given the opportunity to put all your mitigation to the magistrates for their consideration.”

A spokesman for Cumbria police said: “We cannot discuss specific alleged speeding offences while they are subjudice as it may prejudice future court hearings.

“Anyone caught speeding within the nationally agreed limits has the option of either accepting the conditional offer of a fixed penalty, or taking the matter to court where any mitigating circumstances may be considered by the magistrates.”

Have your say

So according to that logic, Mr Duffy has the right to break the speed limit seven times per day, since apparently that is how often his wife suffers seizures. If this had been her first ever seizure I would feel more sympathy. Speaking from experience, the safest thing to do when driving with a passenger who suffers a seizure is to pull over and wait for the seizure to stop before deciding if medical attention is required (it rarely is). As Mr Duffy is his wife's carer, I would have thought he would know the correct way to act in this situation, especially as he says it happens so frequently.

Posted by L Forrester on 12 May 2008 kl. 17:16

Marc - you are quite correct, I agree 100% with your sensible comments.

Posted by V Cords on 12 May 2008 kl. 16:24

View all comments on this article

Make your comment

Your name

Your Email

Your Town/City

Your comment


Vote

Has the Government done enough to solve the 10p tax fiasco?

Yes, it's solved for the moment, giving time to fix it properly later

No, it's costing a fortune and next year we'll be back to square one

Show Result